Free audit
Guide

How to hire a local SEO expert: how to vet one, what to ask in the interview, and the proof worth asking for

Short answer: to hire a local SEO expert, hand each candidate the same thing (your main searches, your city and a baseline of where you show up on Google Maps) and ask them to explain, in plain words, why the top 3 are ahead of you and what they would do first. Then ask for proof from a past business like yours, measured the same way before and after, and check it yourself. Skip anyone who promises a rank or wants to own your Google profile. A small paid first project is the safest way to decide.

What to look for

  • Local, not just SEO. Ask about Google Business Profile categories, review policy, service-area business rules and listings. A website SEO who has never handled a suspended profile is a different hire.
  • Plain explanations. If they cannot explain your situation to you in five minutes, they will not explain a bad month either.
  • Measurement. They should talk about a baseline, a grid across your area, and calls from the profile, not about "rankings" from one spot.
  • Policy knowledge. They should know the business name rules, the review rules and what Google says about third-party managers.

Proof to ask for, and how to check it

Proof What good looks like How to check it
A before-and-after from a similar business Two grids with the same keyword, size, radius and center, dated Ask for the settings. Different settings make the comparison meaningless
Live profiles they worked on A real profile with a real name, recent reviews and replies Open it on Google Maps; read the name and the replies
Listings they built A list of live URLs Click five at random
A sample report Work done, change against baseline, next steps Is there a sentence of explanation for each number?
A reference A current or recent client, in a similar trade Ask the client what changed and how communication was
A written plan for you The first 90 days, specific to your gaps Does it name your competitors and your gaps, or could it be for anyone?

Be fair about what they can share. Many experts sign confidentiality agreements. Anonymized grids and reports are fine, as long as the settings and dates are there.

12 interview questions

Start with Google's own list for hiring an SEO (Google Search Central, read November 11, 2026), which includes "What's your experience in my industry?", "What's your experience in my country/city?" and "What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe? How do you measure your success?" Then add local ones:

  1. Looking at my search, who are the top 3 and what do they have that I don't?
  2. What would you do in the first 30 days, and why in that order?
  3. How do you measure progress, and from where? (Listen for: a grid across the area with fixed settings.)
  4. Which access do you need to my Google Business Profile? (Listen for: manager.)
  5. How do you get reviews without breaking Google's rules?
  6. What would you never do to a business name?
  7. How do you write location or service pages for a town where I have no office?
  8. Tell me about a profile that got suspended. What happened and what did you do?
  9. What do you do yourself, and what do you outsource?
  10. What will a month where nothing moved look like in your report?
  11. What do I own if we stop working together?
  12. What do you need from me each month?

Good answers are specific and a little cautious. "It depends on your competitors; here is what I see in yours" beats "we'll get you to #1."

Red flags

The red flags for an individual expert are the same ones Google lists for any SEO. The full list, in Google's words, is in our local SEO services buyer's guide. Three matter most when you hire one person:

  • A promised rank. Google's hiring advice says "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google."
  • Owner access to your profile. Google's third-party policy says "all end customers must retain ownership or co-ownership of their Business Profile at all times". Manager access is enough for hands-on work.
  • A cold pitch with no facts about you. Google: "Be wary of SEO firms and web consultants or agencies that email you out of the blue."

Add our own: review packages, keyword-stuffed names, and reports with screenshots and no explanation.

Start with a paid trial project

Rather than a long contract, start with a defined project of 2 to 4 weeks:

  1. Scope: an audit against your top 3, plus fixing the top three gaps they find.
  2. Deliverables: a written gap list, the changes made (with dates), and a baseline grid.
  3. Check: after 60 to 90 days, run the same grid again and read their notes.

If the work is clear and the communication is good, move to a monthly plan. Our local SEO proposal template shows what a clear scope looks like, the local SEO services buyer's guide covers what a full engagement should include, and local SEO pricing has what two published surveys say experts charge.

Expert, agency or doing it yourself

Option Choose it when
An individual expert You want one person who knows your account, often for a project or a smaller monthly scope
An agency You need several skills at once (content, links, profiles) and a team that covers holidays
Yourself, with a tool You or a staff member have a few hours a week and want to learn. Start with the local SEO checklist

Once you hire, our checklist is my SEO agency working works for individual experts too.

Where Pack Leader fits

Pack Leader gives you the baseline to bring to the interview and the measurement to check the work later: a Google Maps grid across your area, a competitor audit against the top 3, and AI Search. It is not an expert and does not replace one: it cannot tell you why Google ranks a business, and it does not do the work on your profile. If you are the expert, Pack Leader for freelancers shows how it fits a small client roster.

Frequently asked questions

What does a local SEO expert do?

A local SEO expert, specialist or consultant works on how a business shows up in Google Maps and local search: the Google Business Profile, reviews, listings, location and service pages, local links and tracking. Some do the work; consultants often diagnose and train your team.

How do I know if a local SEO expert is any good?

Ask for before-and-after proof from a business like yours, with the same measurement settings both times, and check it yourself. Ask them to explain your own situation in plain words. Avoid anyone who promises a ranking.

What is the difference between a local SEO specialist, consultant and freelancer?

The titles overlap. A specialist usually does hands-on local work, a consultant usually advises and plans, and a freelancer is self-employed and may do either. Ask what they will do, not what they are called.

How much does a local SEO expert cost?

In Ahrefs' survey of 439 SEO providers (updated August 2024), the most common hourly rate was $75 to $100, and freelancers charged about $1,150 a month on average for local SEO. Rates vary widely by experience and city.

Should a local SEO expert need access to my Google profile?

If they do hands-on work, yes, as a manager. You stay the owner. Google says businesses must keep ownership or co-ownership of their profile at all times.

Keep reading