Short answer: a good local SEO discovery call is 10 minutes and one picture. Before the call, run one Google Maps grid for the prospect's most valuable service. On the call, ask how customers find them, show where they appear in the top 3 and where they don't, show who wins the red areas, and agree on one next step. Don't explain ranking factors and don't promise a position. The script below is word for word, with timings, objection answers and a follow-up message.
Before the call: 15 minutes of prep
- Pick the money service. Not the business name. For a roofer, "roof repair" or "roof replacement", whichever brings bigger jobs. If you don't know, check their website menu.
- Run one grid. A 5×5 at 3 miles from their location is a good default; use a 7×7 at 10 miles for a wide service area. See what grid size and radius to use.
- Note three numbers: top 3 areas, found at how many points, and the business that leads where they are red.
- Compare with that leader: primary category, reviews and how recent they are, photos, website page for the service. Our guide on why a competitor ranks higher lists what to compare.
- Check for rule breaks around them, such as a keyword-stuffed name. Note it, but don't lead with it.
- Take two screenshots: their grid and the leader's grid.
The 10-minute script
Minute 0 to 1: permission and one question
"Thanks for the time. I'll keep this to 10 minutes. Before I show you anything: when a new customer finds you, what do they usually search for?"
Write down their words. If they say a different service than the one you scanned, say so and use your scan anyway, then offer to run theirs after the call.
Minute 1 to 3: their view versus their customers' view
"When you search that on your phone, where do you show up?"
"That's true where you're standing. Google says distance, how far each business is from the person searching, is one of the main things it uses. So your customers across town see a different list. Let me share my screen."
Minute 3 to 5: the grid
"Each dot is the same Google Maps search, from a different spot around your business. Green means you're in the top 3 there, the three businesses people see first. Amber is 4 to 10. Red is lower than that."
"You're in the top 3 at [9] of 25 spots. Most of them are near your shop. Out here [point at red area], you're at [14]."
Let them look. Ask: "Is that area important to you?" If they say no, move to an area they care about.
Minute 5 to 7: who wins where they don't
"In these red spots, this business is first: [competitor]. Here's their map." (Show the leader's grid.)
"Here's what they have that I didn't find on your profile: [for example, about 40 reviews in the last 3 months against your 6, and a category that matches the search]. I can't tell you exactly how Google weighs each one. Nobody outside Google can. But these are the gaps we can actually close."
Keep it to two or three gaps. Use their numbers, not industry averages.
Minute 7 to 9: what you would do, and what you can't promise
"If we work together, the first month is: [fix the category, set up a review request routine, get listed on the 3 directories where they are listed and we did not find you]. I'll run this same map every [week / month], same search, same settings, so you see what moves."
"What I won't do is promise you a spot. Google says there's no way to pay for a better local ranking, and anyone who promises #1 is guessing."
Minute 9 to 10: one next step
"Would it help if I sent you this map so you can look at it with [partner / manager]? Then we can talk [day] about whether the first month makes sense."
Book the follow-up before you hang up.
Objections and honest answers
| They say | You say |
|---|---|
| "I'm #1 when I search." | "You are, right there. Your customers search from home. See why my rank is different on my phone for the reasons." |
| "How long will it take?" | "Some gaps, like a category, are quick to fix. Reviews and listings take months. I'll show you the same map every [month] so you can judge for yourself." |
| "Can you guarantee the top 3?" | "No, and be careful with anyone who does. What I can commit to is the work and the reporting." |
| "My nephew does my website." | "Great, keep him. This is about your Google profile and listings, which sit outside the website." |
| "That competitor is fake." | "If a listing breaks Google's rules, there's a way to report it with evidence. It's slow, and it isn't the first thing I'd do. See spam listing evidence." |
| "We tried SEO before and it didn't work." | "What did they report to you? I'd measure this map, the same way, every month, so you don't have to take my word for it." |
After the call: the follow-up message
Hi [name], thanks for the time today. Here is the map we looked at for "[service]": [link]. Short version: you're in the Google Maps top 3 at [9] of 25 spots, mostly near the shop. [Competitor] leads in [area]. The three gaps I'd start with: [1], [2], [3]. Talk [day] at [time]?
If the second call goes well, the local SEO proposal template gives you the document to send next.
What not to do
- Don't scan their business name. They rank first for it, and it proves nothing.
- Don't change settings between calls. If you show a 7×7 at 10 miles today, show the same next month.
- Don't call a competitor fake on a call. Point to a rule and let Google decide.
- Don't imply a cause you can't show: "you're losing because of X" is a guess. "They have X and we did not find it on your profile" is a fact.
Where Pack Leader fits
Pack Leader gives you the two things this call needs: a Google Maps grid and a competitor audit that puts the prospect's profile next to the 3 businesses that lead their search. To send something after the call, add the prospect as a business in your account and share its client report link.
Be clear with yourself and the prospect about what that link is: a shareable, read-only web page, with "Prepared by" and your agency name at the top. It is not white label: there is no custom logo, colors or domain, and viewers who are not signed in see a "Made with Pack Leader" line. There is no PDF export. The prospect counts toward your plan's business limit. If your sales process needs branded PDFs, use a different tool for that step. For the agency setup, see Pack Leader for agencies.
Frequently asked questions
How do I sell local SEO to a small business?
Show them something they can check themselves, in their own words. A map of where they appear in the Google Maps top 3, for the service that pays their bills, next to the competitor who wins where they don't, does more than any explanation of ranking factors.
Should I promise a top 3 ranking?
No. Google says there is no way to request or pay for a better local ranking, and nobody outside Google controls it. Promise the work and the measurement, not a position.
What grid should I run before a sales call?
One 5x5 grid at about 3 miles for the prospect's main money service, from their business location. Add a 7x7 at 10 miles if they serve a wide area.
What if the prospect says they are already number 1?
They are probably right where they checked, usually near their office. Show the grid points farther out, and explain that Google ranks partly by how far the business is from the person searching.
Can I send the prospect a report after the call?
In Pack Leader you can add the prospect as a business in your account and share its client report link. It is a read-only web page, not a PDF, and it is not white label.