Short answer: review gating is any process that sorts customers by how happy they are before deciding who gets asked for a public review. The classic version is a "How did we do?" screen: 4 or 5 stars go to your Google review page, 1 to 3 stars go to a private form. Google's review policy says merchants may not "Discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers." The FTC says the same practice "could violate the FTC Act." The compliant alternative is simple: send every customer the same request with your direct Google link. (The one-paragraph version is in our glossary under review gating.)
Sources checked November 11, 2026.
What gating looks like
Gating is not only software. All of these sort customers before the ask:
| Practice | Gating? |
|---|---|
| A rating screen that sends 4 and 5 stars to Google and the rest to a private form | Yes |
| Staff hand review cards only to customers who seemed happy | Yes |
| You text the review link only after a customer says "great job" | Yes |
| A survey to everyone, then the Google link only to promoters | Yes |
| A message that tells unhappy customers not to review, or to "call us instead" of reviewing | Yes, it discourages negative reviews |
| The same message with your Google link to every customer | No |
| A survey to everyone, then the Google link to everyone | No |
| A request to every customer that also gives your phone number for problems, with the Google link shown to all | No, in our reading, because nobody is screened out |
Google's rule, word for word
Under "Rating Manipulation", Google's policy says merchants may not:
- "Discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews from customers"
And what is allowed:
- "Solicit or encourage the posting of content that does represent a genuine experience, without offering incentives to do so or attempting to influence the rating or the contents of the review."
Google's Business Profile restrictions page lists what can follow for a business that breaks its fake engagement rules: no new reviews for a set period, existing reviews unpublished for a set period, or a warning that tells consumers fake reviews were removed. That page does not say whether gating alone triggers these, so read it as the range of penalties for review manipulation. Google's own review tips push the other way: "Honest and balanced reviews can help potential customers decide. A mix of positive and negative feedback often feels more trustworthy."
What the FTC says
- In the FTC's Q&A on its consumer review rule, to "Can my business ask for reviews only from customers whom we think are happy with our services?", the answer is: "The rule does not contain a specific prohibition against such conduct," followed by "But this practice could violate the FTC Act."
- The FTC's 2022 guide for marketers says: "Don't ask for reviews only from customers you think will leave positive ones."
- In January 2022 the FTC sent letters to 10 companies offering review management services, warning that "avoiding the collection or publication of negative reviews violates the FTC Act" (FTC press release). The same release announced a $4.2 million settlement with an online retailer the FTC said "suppressed reviews with ratings lower than four stars out of five" on its own website.
- The FTC rule itself bans claiming that reviews shown on your own site represent "most or all" reviews while you hide negative ones (16 CFR 465.7(b)). That matters if you show a filtered review widget on your website.
The compliant alternative
- One message for every customer. Same day, same words, same Google link, whatever you think of the job.
- Offer a direct line to everyone, not instead of the link. Example:
Hi {first name}, thanks for choosing {business}. If you have a minute, we'd value a Google review: {review link}. And if anything wasn't right, you can reach me directly at {phone}. {your name}
- Fix problems fast. A customer who calls you can still review you. You can ask them once, after the fix, if they would like to update their review, without offering anything.
- Reply to every review, good and bad. See how to respond to Google reviews.
More scripts and timing: how to ask for Google reviews and the free review request templates.
Check your own process
- Does anything happen between "job done" and "review link sent" that depends on the customer's mood or rating?
- Does your review software have a setting that sends low ratings somewhere other than Google? Turn it off.
- Do staff decide who gets a review card?
- Does your website widget show only 4 and 5 star reviews while saying it shows all of them?
- Do you count requests sent per completed job? If requests are far fewer than jobs, ask why.
Where Pack Leader fits
Review requests writes messages with your direct Google review link for you to send to every customer, with no rating screen and no reward (review requests). The rules in full: Google's review policy in plain words. For what else Google bans, see paying for Google reviews.
Frequently asked questions
Is review gating illegal?
On Google it breaks the review policy. Under US law, the FTC's review rule has no specific ban on asking only happy customers, but the FTC says the practice could violate the FTC Act, and it has warned review management companies that avoiding the collection of negative reviews violates the FTC Act.
Is a satisfaction survey before the review request gating?
Only if the answer decides who gets the Google link. A survey that every customer gets, followed by the Google link for every customer whatever they answered, is not gating.
Can I ask my happiest customers for a review?
Not only them. Google's policy says merchants may not selectively solicit positive reviews. Ask every customer the same way.
Can I offer a private feedback form?
Yes, if it is offered to everyone and it does not replace or hide the Google review link. The problem is a form that only unhappy customers see instead of the link.