Short answer: search your main services on Google Maps from where your customers are, note the businesses that keep showing up in the top 3, and compare yourself with them on 6 things: primary category, reviews, photos and profile details, distance, listings and links. The gaps where they are ahead and you can catch up are your plan.
Step 1: find your real competitors
- Write down 3 to 5 searches your customers use, for example "emergency plumber" and "water heater repair".
- Search each one on Google Maps in a private browser window, from a few points in your area, not only from your office. To search from a city you are not in, change your Google search location.
- Note which businesses show up in the top 3, and how often. The ones that show up for several searches are your main competitors.
- Leave out directories and lead sites such as Yelp or Angi. They are not businesses you can compare a profile with.
Step 2: compare 6 things
| What to compare | Where to look | What a gap looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Primary category | Under the business name on their profile | They use a category that matches the search better than yours |
| Reviews | Their profile, sorted by newest | More reviews in the last 30 to 90 days than you |
| Photos and profile details | Their profile | More real photos, listed hours, services filled in |
| Distance | The map | They are closer to where customers search. You can't change this, but service area and location pages help with towns nearby |
| Listings | Search their name plus "Yelp", "BBB" and so on | Directories they are on where you are not |
| Links | A backlink tool | Local sites that link to them and not to you |
Also read their reviews for themes: what customers praise and complain about tells you what to promise and what to avoid.
Step 3: turn gaps into a short plan
Sort the gaps into this week (category, hours, photos, a review request routine), this month (listings, service and town pages) and this quarter (links). Skip the gaps you can't close, such as their address or a decade of reviews, and focus on what is moving now. In our Map Pack study, among the top 10 on Google Maps, recent reviews are what differs most (499 searches, recent reviews measured in a 100-search sample). Our 90-day local SEO strategy puts the gaps in order by business type.
Do it in 30 seconds instead
Pack Leader's free local SEO audit runs your searches on Google Maps and compares you with the top 3. The Leader X-ray then puts your profile next to the business that leads your search, row by row: categories, reviews and review pace, rating, photos, hours, website and distance, and says how to close each gap. For listings and links the top 3 have, see the citation checker and the backlink gap tool. To read their reviews side by side with yours, use competitor review analysis.
For the reasons a business can rank above you, read why a competitor ranks higher.
Frequently asked questions
Who are my local competitors?
The businesses that show up in the Google Maps top 3 for the searches your customers use, near your customers. They may differ from the businesses you think of as rivals, and from the sites that rank in regular search results.
How many competitors should I compare with?
Three to five. Start with the business that leads your main search, then the ones that show up in the top 3 for more than one of your searches.
What can't Google Maps tell me about a competitor?
Their revenue, their ad spend, how many calls they get or why Google ranks them where it does. You can see what is public, such as their categories, reviews, photos, listings and links.