Short answer: a local SEO audit checks 6 areas: your Google Business Profile, reviews, Maps rank, listings, website and links. The useful part is not a score out of 100. It is comparing each area with the 3 businesses that lead your search on Google Maps, then fixing the biggest gaps first. They show what it takes in your market.
Step 1: pick your searches and your top 3
Write down 1 to 3 searches your customers use, such as "water heater repair" or "roof replacement". Search each one on Google Maps from your service area, in a private browser window. The businesses in the top 3 are your benchmark. Leave out directories such as Yelp or Angi. Local SEO keywords shows how to find and map them.
Step 2: check the 6 areas
| Area | What to check | Compare with the top 3 |
|---|---|---|
| Google Business Profile | Primary category, hours, website link, verified by owner, photos | Do they use a different primary category? More photos? |
| Reviews | Total, rating, reviews in the last 90 days, owner replies | Who gets reviews faster? |
| Maps rank | Your position for each search, from several points in your area | Where in your area do you drop out? |
| Listings | Your name, address and phone on the main directories, duplicates | Which directories are they on where you are not? |
| Website | City and service in your homepage title, local business schema, location or service pages, a click-to-call link, an FAQ | Do they have pages for services or towns you don't? |
| Links | Websites that link to you | Which sites link to them and not to you? |
Step 3: fix in this order
- Anything that stops you from showing at all: an unverified or suspended profile, a wrong primary category, duplicate profiles. See why a business isn't showing on Google Maps.
- Recent reviews. In our Map Pack study, among the top 10 on Google Maps, recent reviews are what differs most (499 searches, recent reviews measured in a 100-search sample).
- Profile gaps the top 3 close and you don't: photos, categories, hours.
- Listings the top 3 have and you don't. See the local citations guide.
- Website and links, last. In the same study, website checklist items such as the city in the title were about as common below the top 3 as in it. For the pages themselves, see local landing pages and service schema.
Run it for you, free
Pack Leader's local SEO audit runs your searches on Google Maps, takes the top 3, and checks your profile and homepage against them. You get a gap score, your Maps rank next to each competitor, and an action plan of up to 5 fixes ordered by impact. How to read it: how to read your gap report. For the full list of items to keep an eye on, use our local SEO checklist. To write it up for a client, use our local SEO audit template.
Frequently asked questions
What is a local SEO audit?
A check of everything that decides whether you show up in Google Maps and local search results, your Google Business Profile, reviews, listings, website and links, compared with the businesses that rank above you.
How often should I audit?
Once in depth, then a quick check every month or after a big change, such as a move, a new service or a drop in calls.
Which competitors should I compare with?
The 3 businesses in the Google Maps top 3 for your main searches, seen from where your customers are. Leave out directories such as Yelp.
Can I do a local SEO audit for free?
Yes, by hand with the steps on this page. Pack Leader's free plan also runs it for you, against the top 3, in about 30 seconds.