Short answer: review monitoring means knowing about every new review within a day and reading the trend once a month. For most single-location businesses it is free: turn on Google's Customer activity notification, use each review site's own owner app, spend 15 minutes a week replying and checking for policy breaks, and once a month count new reviews against the businesses above you. Paid software earns its cost when you have many locations, sites or people involved.
What to watch
| What | Why it matters | How often |
|---|---|---|
| New reviews on Google | Customers read them and expect a reply | As they come in |
| Unanswered reviews | 89% of consumers in BrightLocal's 2026 survey expect owners to respond | Weekly |
| Reviews that may break the platform's rules | Fake, off-topic or conflict-of-interest reviews can be reported | Weekly |
| New reviews per month | Recency is what customers check | Monthly |
| Star rating trend | A slow slide is easier to fix when you catch it early | Monthly |
| Repeated complaints | Three reviews about the same thing is a process problem, not a reviewer problem | Monthly |
| Competitors' pace and themes | Shows the gap you're up against | Monthly or quarterly |
| Other sites that matter in your trade | Yelp, BBB, Angi, Healthgrades and others | Weekly, through their own alerts |
Survey figures are from BrightLocal's Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 (1,002 US adults, published February 11, 2026). In the same survey, 19% expected a reply the same day, 32% by the next day and 81% within a week. Not sure which sites matter for you? See customer review sites by industry.
Free alerts from Google
Google sends new-review alerts for your Business Profile. From Google's help on managing notifications, checked November 11, 2026:
On a computer:
- Go to your Business Profile.
- Select More, then Notifications.
- Turn on Customer activity. Google describes it as "Alerts when customers leave new reviews or add photos."
In the Google Maps app:
- Open Google Maps.
- At the bottom right, tap Business.
- At the top right, tap Notifications, and turn on the ones you want.
If two people manage the profile, have each of them check their own notification settings.
Alerts from other places
- Each review site's owner account. Yelp, Angi and others have business accounts where you read and answer reviews. Yelp, for example, says to log in to Yelp for Business or use its app to respond.
- Google Alerts for your business name. Google says you "can get emails when new results for a topic show up in Google Search" (Google Alerts help). Put your name in quotes. It catches news and blog mentions, not every review.
- A shared inbox rule. Send all review alert emails to one folder or one shared address, so nothing gets missed when someone is on vacation.
The 15-minute weekly routine
Same day each week, in this order:
- Open the alert folder. List every new review from the last 7 days, on every site that matters.
- Reply to each one. Short and specific. Our positive review response examples and negative review response templates help.
- Flag anything that breaks the rules. On Google, report it from your profile: see report a review. Don't report reviews just for being negative.
- Note the topic of any complaint in one line in a sheet.
- Check last week's reports for a decision.
The monthly check
Keep one sheet with a row per month:
| Month | New Google reviews | Rating | Unanswered | Top complaint | Top competitor's new reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Example: October | 9 | 4.6 | 0 | Late arrival (2) | 14 |
Four questions each month:
- Are new reviews per month going up, flat or down?
- Is the rating moving? Our Google rating calculator guide shows how many reviews it takes to move it.
- Is one complaint showing up again?
- Is the business above you getting reviews faster than you?
In our Map Pack study, among the top 10 on Google Maps, recent reviews are what differs most (499 searches, recent reviews measured in a 100-search sample). That is a correlation, not a cause, but it is a reason to track pace (some call it review velocity), not just the total. Monitoring is one part of the wider routine in reputation management for small business.
When review monitoring software is worth it
| Your situation | Free setup is enough | Software is worth a look |
|---|---|---|
| Locations | 1 or 2 | 5 or more |
| Review sites that matter | Google plus one or two | Many, in several trades or markets |
| Reviews per month | A handful to a few dozen | More than one person can read |
| People who reply | You | A team that needs drafts and approvals |
| Rules | Standard | Health or legal privacy, where every reply gets a second read |
| Reporting | You | Clients or owners who expect a monthly report |
What software adds: one inbox for many sites, alerts by location, reply drafts, approval steps and reports. What it doesn't add: the reviews themselves. No tool can remove a review that follows a platform's rules, and offers to do so for a fee are worth avoiding: see how to get rid of negative Google reviews.
Where Pack Leader fits
Pack Leader is not a real-time review monitor and doesn't send new-review alerts; Google's own notifications do that well. What it does: Review replies loads up to your 200 newest Google reviews, shows how many have no owner reply and drafts an answer for each, which you paste into your profile yourself (how review replies work). Competitor reviews reads the 60 newest Google reviews of you and your top competitor and shows what customers praise and complain about (competitor review analysis). The free local SEO audit puts your review pace next to the top 3. It reads Google reviews only, not Yelp or other sites.
Frequently asked questions
How do I get notified of new Google reviews?
In your Business Profile select More, then Notifications, and turn on Customer activity. Google describes it as alerts when customers leave new reviews or add photos.
How fast should I reply to a new review?
Within a day or two. In BrightLocal's 2026 survey, 32% of consumers expected a reply by the next day and 81% within a week.
Is there a free review checker?
For your own Google reviews, Google's notifications and your Business Profile are free. For other sites, use each platform's own business account. Paid tools mainly save time across many sites or locations.
What should I track besides new reviews?
Unanswered reviews, new reviews per month, your rating trend, recurring complaints, and the same numbers for the businesses above you.
When is review monitoring software worth paying for?
Usually when you have several locations, several review sites that matter, a team that needs approvals, or rules such as health privacy that need a second pair of eyes.